Let's hear some opinions about the current gravel bikes

Hair Face

Well-Known Member
So, I've been enjoying gravel more and more the last couple of years and have been considering upgrading my gravel bike all year long as a result. The problem is I'm so torn on what would be the right bike for me. So I just keep riding my base checkpoint sl5. I don't dislike the bike, it's significantly more comfortable of a ride than the alloy grail it replaced. Has reasonable tire clearance with 47 pathfinder pros squeezed in. And it honestly does everything I need it to do just fine. I just wish it were a little faster and racier feeling, I could just train more and make up any gains that would come from upgrading bikes but new bikes are more fun.

I like the idea of getting a bike with more tire clearance but the reality is most of my "gravel" rides involve just as much riding on pavement as they do dirt and gravel segments so I assume bigger tires would feel slow on the road sections. And most of the local gravel is plenty manageable on 47's so why do I feel the need for larger tires?

As much fun as bike packing sounds, life just wouldn't allow for it so I'm not concerned with having rack mounts.

I have tried the whole underbiking thing and much prefer to ride my mountain bikes on mountain bike trails so no need to get radically slack and am honestly not very concerned about suspension corrected bikes.

I think a Mog would fit my riding well but it's a bit more coin than I'd like to spend and for some reason the fact that it's been out for two years is a deterrent to me. I worry that as soon as I shake out my piggy bank it would be replaced by a new revision. Similar to the Lauf Seigla on the revised design concern though one thing I really like about the Lauf is the option to run mechanical shifting, but since they aren't currently offering any mechanical builds that doesn't really matter. I like shiny objects and have been oogling the new Allied Able but the minimum tire size makes me worried they may have leaned a bit too far into the "big tires=better" game.

I could keep going on and on, but I'll stop there and see if this post gets any traction. What's everyone else currently riding? What would you like to be riding? And what are your opinions about the gravel bike trends?
 

Attachments

  • 149_3rd-3330686-DIGITAL_HIGHRES-9433_014898-70340594.JPG
    149_3rd-3330686-DIGITAL_HIGHRES-9433_014898-70340594.JPG
    78.9 KB · Views: 46
If you like the Checkpoint what about the Checkmate? The new Checkpoint geometry was updated with Gen3 to be more touring/upright, but the Checkmate is geared towards racing. Still not going to be cheap though.
 
I'm looking at the Checkpoint Gen3 for my cross-country trip next year, but not sure how it will handle being fully loaded front and back. My goal was to try to build something that could be an "everything" bike when I get back, just have two wheelsets one with road tires and one with gravel. Not sure if that's a realistic goal or not.
 
I keep debating about this as well... for me, riding gravel would be work. There just isn't enough of it near me to justify a dedicated gravel bike. What I really want is more of an "all-road" bike that is better for longer rides than my GT Grade. Basically, I want a frame with more bottle cage mounts as the GT only has two. I'm currently pondering the Felt Halter's has on close-out, but I need to sell the Orbea Orca I bought first... The Felt looks like it would fit the bill with a few minor changes (mainly swapping out the bars for something more narrow and non-flared).
 
If you like the Checkpoint what about the Checkmate? The new Checkpoint geometry was updated with Gen3 to be more touring/upright, but the Checkmate is geared towards racing. Still not going to be cheap though.

The limited tire clearance is a bit of a put off on the checkmate. Though I was all on board buying a used one that was for sale on here a while back until he changed his mind about selling it.
 
So, I've been enjoying gravel more and more the last couple of years and have been considering upgrading my gravel bike all year long as a result. The problem is I'm so torn on what would be the right bike for me. So I just keep riding my base checkpoint sl5. I don't dislike the bike, it's significantly more comfortable of a ride than the alloy grail it replaced. Has reasonable tire clearance with 47 pathfinder pros squeezed in. And it honestly does everything I need it to do just fine. I just wish it were a little faster and racier feeling, I could just train more and make up any gains that would come from upgrading bikes but new bikes are more fun.

I like the idea of getting a bike with more tire clearance but the reality is most of my "gravel" rides involve just as much riding on pavement as they do dirt and gravel segments so I assume bigger tires would feel slow on the road sections. And most of the local gravel is plenty manageable on 47's so why do I feel the need for larger tires?

As much fun as bike packing sounds, life just wouldn't allow for it so I'm not concerned with having rack mounts.

I have tried the whole underbiking thing and much prefer to ride my mountain bikes on mountain bike trails so no need to get radically slack and am honestly not very concerned about suspension corrected bikes.

I think a Mog would fit my riding well but it's a bit more coin than I'd like to spend and for some reason the fact that it's been out for two years is a deterrent to me. I worry that as soon as I shake out my piggy bank it would be replaced by a new revision. Similar to the Lauf Seigla on the revised design concern though one thing I really like about the Lauf is the option to run mechanical shifting, but since they aren't currently offering any mechanical builds that doesn't really matter. I like shiny objects and have been oogling the new Allied Able but the minimum tire size makes me worried they may have leaned a bit too far into the "big tires=better" game.

I could keep going on and on, but I'll stop there and see if this post gets any traction. What's everyone else currently riding? What would you like to be riding? And what are your opinions about the gravel bike trends?
I’m having exactly the same thought process. No real time for bikepacking and don’t need to feel super slack on gravel roads.

I have been riding an Ibis Hakka for 7 years and I’ve made a gravel bike from a 2016 Ibis Tranny 29. (Same 71 deg HTA) the Tranny has a 100mm lefty from an old scalpel and Maxxis Aspen ST 2.4s. The Hakka runs gravelking X1 40mm

I tried regular stems, redshift stems and berd wheels on the Hakka to play with feel. Unless I’m doing rooty singletrack I don’t think the lefty front suspension makes a difference and I am a believer in the dampening of Berd wheels on harsh terrain so I dumped the redshift stem from the Hakka

On vacations I’ve ridden the Lauf Seigla , Salsa Warroad and Kona Libre. The Warroad and my Hakka are on the twitchy “road” side of ride feel to me while the Seigla and the Libre felt more stable.

My short list of next gravel bikes includes the MOG, the Able and Pinarello Grevil. So much to choose from and very hard to test ride most of those. I think that diving into the geo is fun but so many things change ride feel so not sure how to choose.
 
I don't dislike the bike, it's significantly more comfortable of a ride than the alloy grail it replaced. Has reasonable tire clearance with 47 pathfinder pros squeezed in. And it honestly does everything I need it to do just fine. I just wish it were a little faster and racier feeling,

Based on these requirements, the best bang for your buck IMHO would be to get a nice set of carbon wheels for the current bike. I have a friend that has a newer SL5 and he just did that (i think he got some ENVE wheels) but I was with him for the first ride on the new wheels and he told me it feels like a different bike.

Like you, I won't ride my gravel bike on single track or plan any big adventures where I need to load it up. I could see maybe one day trying like the Bike trip/airBnB thing but not for more than a long weekend.

I think mentioned when we rode together, I probably would still have my Gen2 ALR5 if my current Gen2 SL7 didnt come my way for a deal I could not pass up. It came with Aeolus Prov37 wheels which are like buttah. I was planning to get a new set of wheels for the ALR5 to accomplish the same thing.

I also have a set of aluminum wheels with 32mm tires that I swap out when I want to use the gravel bike on the roads during the crappy weather season and if the Gravel roads/trails are too messy. The only real slightly limiting factor is the ALR5 was a 2x and the SL7 is a 1x.

Edit: P.S. I am pretty sure you dont need new wheels to go faster*
 
Last edited:
I personally have a 2020 Cannondale Topstone that I'm stuck fitting at most 40mm tires and I primarily use it for underbiking. Liking the Topstone I would consider a Cannondale SuperX if I was looking for a racier gravel bike. Are you looking for 1x or 2x?
 
As far as tire clearance goes, Just about all of my gravel rides are 50/50 road and dirt. I find that 40s are just fine for that mix. Then again I’ve never been on 45s on the road so I wouldn’t listen to anything I’m saying!

The only reason I would go bigger is for a specific ride that I know will have chunkier gravel, but then you start to blur the underbiked line.
 
S-Works Crux /thread
What's your recommendation for a "Do it all" setup that can be light enough for road rides and can be set up for cross-country touring and gravel? Is there such a thing if you have two wheelsets? The grtavel i'm riding would be of the Bedminster type so I'm planning on running the same type of tires as I would for the cross-country trip (i.e. Panaracer Gravel King slicks or maybe Continental Terra Speeds etc.).
 
Last edited:
I've been going through a similar thought process with the Mog. From what they're saying it's just another color refresh come the spring and honestly can't imagine much change coming to gravel geo/features in the next couple years.

I'm rolling with my Rocky Mountain Solo which can fit 55mm tires and has super similar geometry until the spring I think. I have been thoroughly enjoying the 55's lately. Am I giving up watts on the road? For sure. Is it way more fun on gravel? Hell yes. I'm actually descending with some confidence lately.

What about the Able? Way more race-y geo and still plenty of clearance for whatever gravel tires you want.
 
What's your recommendation for a "Do it all" setup that can be light enough for road rides and can be set up for cross-country touring and gravel? Is there such a thing if you have two wheelsets? The grtavel i'm riding would be of the Bedminster type so I'm planning on running the same type of tires as I would for the cross-country trip (i.e. Panaracer Gravel King slicks or maybe Continental Terra Speeds etc.).

I rode an S-Works Crux for 2 years as my only road/gravel/ultra/bikepacking bike and it was great. Except I want to own a bike for every day of the week so I split my 1 do it all bike into 6 bikes 😂
 
I rode an S-Works Crux for 2 years as my only road/gravel/ultra/bikepacking bike and it was great. Except I want to own a bike for every day of the week so I split my 1 do it all bike into 6 bikes 😂
I don't think the Crux has rack and fork mounts though, correct? I'm thinking on running front and rear packs, I'm planning on camping maybe 50% of the trip depending on how I feel. I was trying this setup out on my current "gravel" bike. Please ignore the untrimmed steerer tube, thank you. 😀

PXL_20251024_193649325.jpg
 
I personally have a 2020 Cannondale Topstone that I'm stuck fitting at most 40mm tires and I primarily use it for underbiking. Liking the Topstone I would consider a Cannondale SuperX if I was looking for a racier gravel bike. Are you looking for 1x or 2x?

I've ridden both and don't really have a preference. Probably wind up going 1x considering the current offerings.
 
Back
Top Bottom