Cars, it's electric! Do Do Do

Hopefully everyone sees the writing on the wall and makes everything modular for ease of recycling and repair. IMO the most obsolete thing about electric cars are their battery, as the batteries we use in EV's are just barely good enough.

yea thatll never happen, hell arent the tesla (and others im sure) batteries integrated into the frame, meaning PART OF THE STRUCTURE? how the hell do you change that? new frame for the car?
 
  • Like
Reactions: don
Sunroofs that don't leak, body panels that are lined up, power steering that doesn't crap out, brakes that work, suspension that doesn't break? Realistically though, I don't care what they need since I have zero interest in ever over-paying for one.
Tesla's don't have sunroofs. Panel gaps are an issue, enough to make Carson vomit. Power steering is fine. Brakes are great and no issues with suspension. I can't speak for other EV's as I only have a Model 3.
yea thatll never happen, hell arent the tesla (and others im sure) batteries integrated into the frame, meaning PART OF THE STRUCTURE? how the hell do you change that? new frame for the car?
The batteries are in a structural pack and it can be replaced. At one point I think they looked into how fast to swap out batteries and it was about 90 seconds.
 
Tesla's don't have sunroofs. Panel gaps are an issue, enough to make Carson vomit. Power steering is fine. Brakes are great and no issues with suspension. I can't speak for other EV's as I only have a Model 3.

The batteries are in a structural pack and it can be replaced. At one point I think they looked into how fast to swap out batteries and it was about 90 seconds.
Model S did come with a sunroof but the stopped offering it because....It leaked. All the other issues are known or have been part of a recall, not that other cars don't get those either. Panel gaps are ok for some but wouldn't be for me in ANY $50k plus vehicle because they point to an overall lack of attention to detail, workmanship, and poor quality control. If the parts you can see are misaligned, what about the parts you can't see?
 
Model S did come with a sunroof but the stopped offering it because....It leaked. All the other issues are known or have been part of a recall, not that other cars don't get those either. Panel gaps are ok for some but wouldn't be for me in ANY $50k plus vehicle because they point to an overall lack of attention to detail, workmanship, and poor quality control. If the parts you can see are misaligned, what about the parts you can't see?
My $18K Hyundai didn't have panel gaps, so I don't see how it is okay for anything other than a Yugo. I tolerate it on the Model 3, but hope they get that figured out. Tesla seems to sort out a lot of things as they go forward and don't update bodies as often as other cars.
I think Tesla sunroofs were stopped 5 years ago. I was never a fan of sunroofs or T tops on any cars, with T tops being the worst.
 
yea thatll never happen, hell arent the tesla (and others im sure) batteries integrated into the frame, meaning PART OF THE STRUCTURE? how the hell do you change that? new frame for the car?
That's interesting, as I was thinking that the evolution of long recharging times would have been replacing the entire battery in a swift move instead of plugging and wait for the recharge to complete. The batteries could then be recharged offline. That would require a standard form factor(s) for batteries.
 
That's interesting, as I was thinking that the evolution of long recharging times would have been replacing the entire battery in a swift move instead of plugging and wait for the recharge to complete. The batteries could then be recharged offline. That would require a standard form factor(s) for batteries.

the process could also be automated.
I thought a hybrid solution of fixed and replaceable packs would be best.
self centering cylinder, arm pulls it out and places on a charger, another puts the new one in. off ya go.

might also have to do with crash safety.
 
looks like the battery swap require an entire interior removal on the teslas as of this point


not something you want to be doing with any frequency, but doesnt look much worse than an engine swap. . . .



EDIT: looks like reports for model s are 3-13 hours (and 12k-15k) to replace batteries (much more than a new engine in a gas/diesel vehicle)
 
  • Like
Reactions: don
looks like the battery swap require an entire interior removal on the teslas as of this point


not something you want to be doing with any frequency, but doesnt look much worse than an engine swap. . . .



EDIT: looks like reports for model s are 3-13 hours (and 12k-15k) to replace batteries (much more than a new engine in a gas/diesel vehicle)
Well on our way to the electric revolution!
 
the process could also be automated.
I thought a hybrid solution of fixed and replaceable packs would be best.
self centering cylinder, arm pulls it out and places on a charger, another puts the new one in. off ya go.

might also have to do with crash safety.
Automated charging station for domestic use including two main battery pack capacity (one charging while the other is on the car), with a lightweight core battery that stays on the car and allows for short range mobility with the main battery pack removed, also thanks to the weight reduction of the vehicle resulting from it. You’re welcome Elon…
 
Automated charging station for domestic use including two main battery pack capacity (one charging while the other is on the car), with a lightweight core battery that stays on the car and allows for short range mobility with the main battery pack removed, also thanks to the weight reduction of the vehicle resulting from it. You’re welcome Elon…

so like a flux capacitor?
 
You think manufacturers are going to make things that are easy to fix and they won't purposely obsolete their own technology and standards to drive sales? Kind of like bikes? Are you serious or just being sarcastic?
Really? Fix what? I don't know about other EVs, but I checked the recommended maintenance (every 10K miles) out to 100,000 miles on my Ford MME and it's rotate tires (every 10K) and replace cabin filter (every 20K). That's it. Everything else is just checks.

I have 24K on it and it has cost me zip in maintenance and repairs. Time will tell on future reliability but so far so good. Battery warranty is 8 years/100,000 miles. And, oh, BTW, fit and finish were perfect. I think I can easily keep this car long term with no issues. Plus, it's a blast to drive.
 
You think manufacturers are going to make things that are easy to fix and they won't purposely obsolete their own technology and standards to drive sales? Kind of like bikes? Are you serious or just being sarcastic?
In the approximate 120 years of cars what major manufacturer has made any of their vehicles obsolete? There has been an undeniable improvement in reliability and reduced maintenance, so why would we predict that trend will change? Example oil changes went from 3k to 10k+ and cars today are easily pulling 200k with little to no reduced drive quality. Manufactures learned from GM’s and Hyundai’s crap vehicles in the 80/90s that customers value longevity and reputation has a marketable value. This is especially true now that car manufacturers are selling their cars twice, once leased then CPO. It’s reasonable to believe in a competitive market that if customer’s indicate they want a long lasting easy to swap battery car, at least one of the manufacturers will make it. This will happen when EV’s are out of the Lexus market and into the Toyota market. (Why Toyota pilots new tech in Lexus, b/c they don’t own their cars for long and don’t care about longevity) . And bike companies don’t make their bikes obsolete, they just make better bikes… like they’re supposed to… in which case I don’t want to repair my old one… but I could. You can get 142 hubs if you want. I have a 20 yr old bike in my basement, not a single part can’t be replaced. Some people are trying to compare to computers/phones, but that is different, they become obsolete mainly because the tasks we ask them to do are continually more rigorous… just compare a persons average data usage over the last 10years… drastically different.. but cars have been doing the same thing for the last 100years maybe just a slight increase in miles driven per year and the increased demands revolve around efficiency and safety.
 
Really? Fix what? I don't know about other EVs, but I checked the recommended maintenance (every 10K miles) out to 100,000 miles on my Ford MME and it's rotate tires (every 10K) and replace cabin filter (every 20K). That's it. Everything else is just checks.

I have 24K on it and it has cost me zip in maintenance and repairs. Time will tell on future reliability but so far so good. Battery warranty is 8 years/100,000 miles. And, oh, BTW, fit and finish were perfect. I think I can easily keep this car long term with no issues. Plus, it's a blast to drive.

Fix implies repair not scheduled maintenance. Hell even gas cars anymore hardly ever break down. Maintenance is a part of owning a vehicle and even evs will wear tires and brakes among other things. And they do have fluids and coolants in board which also have a lifespan (probably similar to the 10yr 150k mile lifespan of modern engine coolants).

By your logic my truck has cost me zip in 115k miles too (since maintainenance isn't considered in your equation)
 
  • Like
Reactions: don
Fix implies repair not scheduled maintenance. Hell even gas cars anymore hardly ever break down. Maintenance is a part of owning a vehicle and even evs will wear tires and brakes among other things. And they do have fluids and coolants in board which also have a lifespan (probably similar to the 10yr 150k mile lifespan of modern engine coolants).

By your logic my truck has cost me zip in 115k miles too (since maintainenance isn't considered in your equation)

Yeah but these are both n=1 observations. No question that an EV has a lot less mechanical parts to go south.
 
Yeah but these are both n=1 observations. No question that an EV has a lot less mechanical parts to go south.
They still have suspensions, and electric motors as well as electronics needed to control them are subject to wear and failure. How often do you (plural) change your phone? I’m sure quality is up there but stuff do happen.
 
Damn is this what ya’ll do in your spare time? Just shit on cars you don’t actually daily drive. Stuff happens to any car. Buy what you want and can and deal with it. Love my EVs over the last 8 years and approaching 100k gas free miles and never a leaking roof or sunroof which I miss. I think I’m going to roll out of bed in 30 to ride 6mile before the rain.
Photo of result of my new foam cannon
09F6C7E4-276E-410F-84BD-CC5EF18D5E35.jpeg

I’m not talking cars here but sustainability wise I’ve given up on influencing anyone. It’s either you care or you don’t. Companies don’t. Just stop buying junk, filling landfills, and reuse/upcycle. Services batteries, there is a growing number of Indy techs who can do the job better and cheaper.
 
Last edited:
GM’s and Hyundai’s crap vehicles in the 80/90

And they were superior to cars before them.
alternators, starters, and water pumps were every few years
spark plugs lasted 30k, wires got brittle
points, rotor, distributor cap annually.
interior door handles pulling off cause they were screwed into the sheet metal, or the plastic would pull off the head of the screw
cause the door was so heavy.

that is if the body held together long enough. disappearing rocker panels and fender lips.

I like that I can order pre-painted body panels now!
 
They still have suspensions, and electric motors as well as electronics needed to control them are subject to wear and failure. How often do you (plural) change your phone? I’m sure quality is up there but stuff do happen.
Electric motors + 1 sp transmission has 10% of the moving parts of an ICE + transmission. And new cars have just as much electronic controls if not more.
 
Yeah but these are both n=1 observations. No question that an EV has a lot less mechanical parts to go south.

yes thats my point, i was taking his own argument to an extreme to make it.


mechanical parts probably (the engine/transmission do make up the bulk of parts on a traiditional vehicle) but evs have more computers and software to have issues with. But the engine/transmission problems are pretty rare on modern cars anyway(especially below 100k miles)

I’m not talking cars here but sustainability wise I’ve given up on influencing anyone. It’s either you care or you don’t. Companies don’t. Just stop buying junk, filling landfills, and reuse/upcycle. Services batteries, there is a growing number of Indy techs who can do the job better and cheaper.

did you read the paper from volvo posted earlier in this thread? in order for an ev to generate the same amount of carbon emissions than a comparable ice powered vehicle it needs to be owned/driven something like 92k miles and it doesnt account for battery replacement in that window (im not sure if it includes the disposal portion of the lifecycle either) How many people do you know that keep a car that long (im sure many of us in this thread keep ya longer than that, but that is definitely NOT the norm.

also what actually happens to the old batteries? i cant find any companies that actually disassemble them and resuse the materials, im guessing they all get shipped to a landfill in china . . . .
 
Back
Top Bottom